Who has the best Ice Cream/Custard?

I'll shoot Kill Devil Custard in KDH and Fatty's in Buxton - love Hersheys.

12 replies

I'll second Kill Devil Custard. Although their milkshakes are a little too thick.

John's Drive In in Kitty Hawk

Snow Birds Nags Head. It's a nice treat after lunch.

I'm a dairy queen guy.

Fudgery. Haven't been there yet this season. I love their chillers but the location in nags head didn't have it last year.

As a person who is lucky enough to be surrounded by creameries at home, who has the best in Nags Head? Clogging a milkshake straw to me is a positive indicator of quality.

@Greg Hands down Surfin Spoon. Cool atmosphere too.

@Greg - You use a straw????? Hmmmm.....

I guess technically it’s not “ice cream” but we love Surfin Spoon

Big Bucks. Homemade with a lot of locations.

Can children vote? Ocracoke Ice Cream Co.

@BentMtn It keeps my mustache clean 😆